Review of The Art of Unit Testing

The Art of Unit Testing With Examples in .NET by Roy Osherove, published by Manning. ISBN: 1933988274

Introduction

The Art of Unit Testing aims to teach developers how to write maintainable, readable and trustworthy unit tests. The author Roy Osherove has recently moved over to the Ruby community but is well-known in the .NET world for his TDD courses and TDD katas. He previously worked at TypeMock as Chief Architect so he lived and breathed unit tests for a few years.

This book is not what I had expected after reading all the online reviews. It is most definitely a beginner’s book, a book for someone just starting out with TDD. The first two books I read when getting started with TDD were Working Effectively with Legacy Code by Michael Feathers and Growing Object-Oriented Software, Guided by Tests by Steve Freeman and Nat Pryce. The Art of Unit Testing refers heavily to them and I would describe it as an introduction to unit testing. I noticed that The Art of Unit Testing placed above them on Jurgen Appelo’s Top 100 Agile Books list and I do not understand that to be honest. It would have been the perfect text for me during the first month of beginning TDD but feels mostly redundant after reading the two afore mentioned books.

The Meat of the Book

The Art of Unit Testing is well-written and easy to read, I flew through it in a few sessions. The first three chapters are a very basic introduction to unit testing. It gets a bit more interesting after that with nice, clear explanations of stubbing and mocking in chapters 4 to 6. Chapter 6 also contains a section on creating a test API that I really liked. It is the section of the book that I am most likely to reread later. Chapter 7 goes a bit deeper into writing tests and is the most interesting part of the book. It manages to gather together most of the good tips on unit testing that I have seen before e.g. enforcing test isolation, practising DRY even in your tests, keep setup code simple, avoiding overspecification. Chapter 8 is non-technical and is about getting your organisation to start unit testing. The rest of the book lists the various unit testing tools and frameworks available as well as the classic TDD books that you should read.

The parts that could be better

The lists of tools has not dated too well. The book is written in 2009 and a lot has changed in two years. Mocking frameworks like NSubstitute and FakeItEasy are not included and Rhino Mocks gets a lot of attention. The newer BDD tools like Specflow are also not included. Those sections will be near worthless in a couple of years time.

The last chapter on working with legacy code is very skimpy for a subject that is both huge and difficult. And generally, a lot more could have been written about unit testing. Nothing about Object Mothers or Test Builders (check out this article from Los Techies or read Growing Object-Oriented Software, Guided by Tests). Not much on GUI testing with Selenium or integration testing the database or the BDD-style of testing. When I write code I do not really separate writing production code and writing unit tests, the two go hand in hand. And this makes the book less valuable than a good book on TDD even if I can understand why the author chose to do so. There are a lot of .NET developers out there who know nothing about unit testing or TDD and something like GOOS would scare off most of them.

The formatting of the code samples is dreadful, the alignment is off in almost half of them. You can still read and understand them but it feels low quality. I am reading another Manning book at the moment and its formatting is fine so I cannot understand how that got in to the final version.

And the verdict is…

I would recommend The Art of Unit Testing for anyone getting started with writing unit tests but not if you have been doing TDD for a while and have already read some of the recommended texts on TDD. It’s a nice, smooth read and very easy to absorb but it is only about unit testing and not TDD (a minus for me) and there is almost nothing about writing testable code, a huge part of testing in my opinion.

About Daniel Lee

Irishman living and working in Sweden. DotNet developer/consultant at Active Solution.
This entry was posted in Book Review and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Review of The Art of Unit Testing

  1. royosherove says:

    Thanks for the review. I fully agree, that if you got through GOOS, then this book will be relatively less interesting to you. This book is usually for relative beginners in this world, and is specifically NOT about TDD. I’d recommend GOOS as a good book on TDD, and my book as a good book about *unit testing*.
    It’s also not about integration testing, as it is a unit testing book, and I tried to focus on just one thing, done well.

    I appreciate the formatting comments as well. I think most of it was my fault, trying to ‘deliver’ this baby to the world quickly. If I do a next version, I will take care of that.

    Roy.

    • Daniel Lee says:

      It is definitely a book that is much needed in the .NET community. Still too many devs not doing TDD or writing unit tests. I would recommend it to a colleague who does not unit test or is just starting.

  2. Pingback: Developing with .NET – Which Unit Test framework to use – MSTest or NUnit? | ALMPEOPLE

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s